The card must be able to be built-around in multiple ways in the format (sorry The Rack, Scapeshift, and Ad Nauseam, you don't count.) At least one deck that uses the card must be Modern viable at the time of this publication Now with only ten spots to use, I know I'll inevitably leave out some favourites, so please don't be shy in the comments with some honorable mentions
Come see all our Fate Reforged spoiler coverage Mob Rule They basically reprinted Insurrection
I don't think it was intentional, but in the absence of one very specific villain from the set, there's a malaise that surrounds the rest of these detestable, forgettable villains
Magic: The Gathering s upcoming Innistrad: Midnight Hunt set is packed with solid Rare and Mythic Rare cards, but only eight make the cut as first picks within Limited Draft
Perhaps you could start by using your authority as un-Rules Manager to nix the rule for silver-bordered games